Spotlight on: Silk – The Life and Times of Cindy Moon

To my utter dismay, it was announced last month that Marvel has canceled the Silk ongoing series. While the series is admittedly, not as popular as the likes of Spider-Gwen, Deadpool, or even Squirrel Girl, it contains a truly compelling story, and a highly relatable lead, in the form of Cindy Moon, aka, Silk!

With that in mind, it felt necessary to go back and spotlight Silk’s first trade, The Life and Times of Cindy Moon.

Introduced in the Original Sin story arc, the addition of Cindy Moon to the Marvel universe seems like yet another attempt to reskin the popular Spider-Man character, just to make a quick buck. Female counterparts to Spider-Man, are not even that rare, with the existence of Spider-Girl (May-day Parker) the daughter of Peter Parker and Mary Jane in an alternative future, Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew) an Avenger and now mother, and the alternative universe Spider-Gwen (Gwen Stacy) that was bitten by the spider in place of Peter. That leads to the question, what makes Silk stand out, and why should you care?

While the likes of Spider-Man and his other web-slinging counterparts, tend to focus heavily on their never ending rogue’s gallery, jumping from a monster of the week ordeals to multi-part battles for the fate of the world. Silk’s crime fighting antics act as a backdrop to her story, and a way to establish herself within the Marvel universe than anything. The driving force behind her heroism is her determination to find what she left behind. Creating a truly unique edition to the Spider line up, and a genuine joy to read.

Cindy Moon, brought to life in the pages of The Amazing Spider-Man, provides a stark contrast to Peter. Having been bitten by the same radioactive spider that gave Peter his web-slinging powers, Cindy is hidden away from the world, in order to protect the ones she loved from her seemingly uncontrollable powers. Having been set free 10 years later, Cindy has to face the world alone, unsure of how to proceed other than the example set forth by Peter and her memories of better times. Her interesting relationship with Peter Parker hammers home just how different the same set of circumstances can be when a different extreme is taken, but how both choices meant loosing something close to them. That there was no easy answer, no right choice.

Cindy’s use of pop culture references, while this would usually heavily date the comic a few years down the line, work wonderfully in helping to shape Cindy’s personality and the time frame her mind is still stuck in. Making references to the Pokemon franchise, in its first few pages to only question if that’s still a thing, and highlighting her preference for paper and pen to the modern day tablet or phone. The inclusion of Cindy’s natural eidetic memory is a breath of fresh air, feeling that she has been “adjusting to powers” her whole life, bringing up just how painful this kind of ability can be especially when you lose something, or in this case people you love. Combining her natural abilities with her spider powers creates a new look at the spider based heroes. While Peter puts more focus into being Spider-Man out of a sense of responsibility, frequently forgetting his obligations as Peter Parker. Cindy is unable to forget her driving force, with finding her family being the top priority for both identities. The notion of Cindy working as an intern at a news site may appear as an attempt to simply mimic the early career of Peter Parker. However, it makes a lot of sense for her character. Cindy’s need to readjust herself to the modern world as well as finding leads to the overarching detective work of the series plays out beautifully and even leads to some fascinating and adorable scenes between both Cindy and J. Jonah Jameson.

The artwork is delightfully stylised, with the elegant ability to show both the fast sweeping action of battle scenes , and to slow down seamlessly for the sombre and isolated moments down in the bunker. The use of colour throughout, while not especially focus on delicate shading, is vibrant with a somewhat minimalistic approach. Knowing when to burst with colour and when to fade into the memories. Characters are easily distinguishable and visually striking creating an incredibly engaging and seamless read.

Silk: The Life and Times of Cindy Moon, contains all 7 issues and while some prior knowledge of the events in Amazing Spider-Man may prove helpful, they are completely non-compulsory to enjoy this largely self-contained tale.

Written by Robbie Thompson, with art by Stacey Lee. Silk – The Life and Times of Cindy Moon, is available in both Trade Paperback and Hardcover.

 

 

Advertisements

Laughing in the face of the Original: [Academic Paper]

Does the intertextual nature of the parody genre effect how we see an original text?

Abstract:

This essay explore the nature of Intertextuality and its use in the parody genre. Exploring subjects such as Semiotics, Genre Subversion, Ghost Texts and Postmodernism. While drawing on a large pool of artefacts, this essay focuses primarily on the works of Mel Brooks, specifically the films Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1987], Blazing Saddles [Brooks. 1974] and Spaceballs [Brooks. 1974].

Introduction:

In the study of semiotics, the practice of deriving meaning from signs and signifiers [Chandler. 2014], there exists the study of intertextuality. While the study of semiotics has been defined by Umberto Eco as being “concerned with everything that can be taken as a sign” [Eco. 1976:7], and hence, deriving meaning from those signs based on cultural significance and context, then intertextuality is the practice of such signs and signifiers, drawing on specific cultural materials, such as films, books, television and other media. While intertextuality can be seen in multiple examples, the practice of recognising such references can vary depending on the readers own frame of reference. Bazerman notes that intertextual references are “most easily recognizable when the textual borrowings involve some distance in time, space, culture, or institution. Phrases that are common and unremarkable in sports such are ‘stepping up to the plate’ – just part of the ordinary way of talking that everyone shares – become a bit remarkable when they start appearing in political contexts, such as when congressperson talks about courage to take a stand on an issue by talking about ‘stepping up to the plate’.” [Bazerman. 2004:89] Bazerman uses this as an example to how a common baseball metaphor can become part of the public lexicon, even outside of the realm of sports.
The term intertextuality, was introduced by Julia Kristeva, in her 1966 essay, Words, Dialogue and Novel [Kristeva. 1980], and later expounded upon in her 1966-67 essay, The Bounded Text [Kristeva. 1980]. The original definition Kristeva proposed, described it as the “initiated [proposal of a] text as a dynamic site in which relational processes and practices are [focuses] of analysis instead of static structures and products” [Friedman. 1991:147]. Since introducing this concept, the idea and the notion of intertextuality has been expounded upon by theorists such as, Harold Bloom [Bloom. 1973], Susan Friedman [Friedman. 1991], and Henry Jenkins. In 1977, Roland Barthes introduced the idea of ‘The Death of the Author’ [Barthes. 1977], a notion that is often paired, and discussed alongside intertextuality. Barthes discusses whether or not the authors opinion and intention in regards to their own work should be taken into account, once the work is published. In regards to intertextuality, this provides an interesting notion. When reconstituting an author’s work, for example, into the guise of a comedy, would the initial author agree with the new outcome?

The use of intertextuality, can be defined by three key categories, obligatory, optional, and accidental [Miola. 2004]. Obligatory intertextuality involves the use of deliberate referencing, the writer will invoke texts of consciously, and the reader will usually require some form of knowledge towards the original texts, in order to appreciate the new material created [Fitzsimmons. 2013]. Examples of this can frequently be seen in The Simpsons Halloween Specials [Groening, Brooks & Simon. 1989 – Present]. Unlike standard episodes of The Simpsons which may incorporate intertextuality into their stories, most stories told in the annual ‘Treehouse of Horror’ [Archer, Moore, & Silverman. 1990] episodes are parodies or retellings of existing horror properties. For example, the first story of Treehouse of Horror V [Reardon. 1994], entitled The Shinning, is a recreation of the Stanley Kubrick 1980 horror film, The Shining [Kubrick. 1980]. Replacing Jack Nicholson’s character, Jack Torrance, with Homer Simpson, Shelley Duvall, with Marge, and Danny with Bart. Optional Intertextuality, most notably refers to intertextual references that are none-essential to the story being told, but are used “to pay homage to the ‘original’ writers, or to reward those who have read the [text]. However, the reading of this [text] is not necessary to the understanding of the [new text]” [Ivanic. 1998]. Finally, Accidental Intertextuality, involves the unconscious referencing of texts in an author’s work [Fitzsimmons. 2013].This usually occurs when the writer makes no clear intention of making a specific intertextual reference, though connections could still be made by readers who may recognise subtle references [Wohrle. 2012].
A Genre that relies implicitly on intertextuality, is that of the Parody genre. The genre is defined by its use of Obligatory intertextuality, using specific subjects, genres, themes, or tropes, and using them as a source of comedy. When discussing parody in there book Film Art: An Introduction [Bordwell & Thompson. 2003], Bordwell and Thompson use the genre of horror to explore the purpose and popularity of parody. “Horror classics have been remade (Cat People [Tourneur. 1942], Dracula [Browning. 1931]), and the genre conventions have been parodied (Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1974], Beetlejuice [Burton. 1988]).” “By the late 1990s, horror-film conventions had become so familiar that parodies also became popular: Men in Black [Sonnenfeld. 1997], Men in Black II [Sonnenfeld. 2002], and the Scary Movie [Wayans. 2000] and Scream [Craven. 1996] series. Whatever the causes, filmmakers working in horror films have maintained that dynamic of conventions and innovation that is basic to every film genre” [Bordwell & Thompson. 2003:123]. The genre of parody is nothing new, elements can be found dating “back to Aristophanes (448 – 380? B.C.) spoofing the writing styles of Aeschylus Euripides in the Frogs, or Cervantes’ undercutting of the medieval romance genre in his early seventeenth-century novel Don Quixote, whose title character argumentatively is Western culture’s greatest comic figure” [Gehring. 1999:01]. The parody genre, as it appears in film, is of no surprise, the evolution of multiple other genres on screen, for example the horror or action genre, has allowed the parody genre to evolve alongside it. Notably, the works of Mel Brooks can be seen as prime examples. Including Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1974], playing on the themes and events of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein [Shelley. 1818], Spaceballs [Brooks. 1987], parodying the Star Wars [Lucas. 1977] franchise, and Blazing Saddles [Brooks. 1974], subverting tropes and expectations of the Western genre.

Young Frankenstein and ‘The Death of the Author’:

With parody, and the use of intertextuality, it is worth wondering of the ‘original’ author’s reaction to their work being parodied. In the case of Frankenstein [Shelley. 1818], famously parodied in Mel Brooks’ Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1974], a property intended to terrify its readers. Originally created by Shelley as part of a friendly writing competition between herself, Percy Shelley, Lord Byron, and John Polidori, in an attempt to create the best horror story they could [Whitebloom. 2011] [Baldalamenti. 2006], Brooks transforms the work of horror, in to a dark comedy starring famed comedian Gene Wilder. Brooks takes the notion of man becoming god, and realising the sheer horror of his mistake, and takes it apart piece by piece, for the comedic entertainment of the masses. It is far to say that Shelley herself is not guilty of intertextuality herself, the evidence to which is in the full title to her novel, Frankenstein; or The Modern Prometheus [Shelley. 1818]. Shelley story evokes the myth of Prometheus, and the poem Paradise Lost [Milton. 1667], “Shelley uses the myth of Prometheus and Paradise Lost in an ambivalent mode; they maintain their original meaning, but, at the same time, they acquire a specific feature that suits the novel better. For instance, the archetypical figure of Prometheus is represented by a mortal man, which changes significantly the outcome of the story. Besides, the figure of a divine creator, Prometheus in the Greek mythology or God in Milton’s epic, is transformed into a fallible mortal man in the novel” [Alves. 2014:132].

Barthes theory of ‘The Death of the Author’, applies, in this case, not only to Shelley’s work, but the myth of Prometheus and Milton’s epic poem. As Friedman states, in here essay Weaving: Intertextuality and the (Re)Birth of the Author [Friedman. 1991], “The ‘author’ dies in Barthes’s text in more ways than one. Like Kristeva, he sees the ‘author’ or ‘writer’ vanishing into the play of signifiers on the page” [Friedman. 1991:148]. She goes on to add, “the ‘death of the author’ – and with ‘him’, the death of origin, meaning, and referentiality – make possible the transformation of ‘the work’ into the ‘Text’ and the ‘Text’ as a performative state of engagement with other texts: in short, intertextuality” [Friedman. 1991:149]. With this in mind, it is useful to think of each of the texts being parodied, or referenced, as being similar to the multiple parts used to create Frankenstein’s monster. Each text dead, having been freed from their original authors control at publication, and now free to be stitched and rearranged by new authors, or literary Dr. Frankenstein’s. As Barthes states “the birth of the reader must be ransomed by the death of the author” [Barthes. 1977: 06], in regards to intertextuality, this plays a large part when arguing authorial intent, as the author’s work could be quoted or referenced in a manner in which the original author finds offensive, or against their wishes. In regards to parody, this may put the new text in binary opposition with the original, creating a juxtaposition within itself. With Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1974], a horror story is being transferred to a comedy, and while the question may be asked as to whether or not Shelley would want her creation being seen that way, the same could be asked if Milton would have been pleased with his epic poem being used as fuel for one of literatures most enduring monsters.

The key principle in Barthes’ theory, is that once a text has been published, and people outside of the author are able to read, view and absorb the text, then the authors role is finished, the author is essentially dead in the eyes of the text, and this allows for the birth of the readers. With the death of the author, it is reasonable to assume, that the intent of the author is no longer valid, that it is now in the hands of the reader, and possible new authors, to breathe new life into the text, and interpret it in the manner they see fit. In this case, intertextuality is the practice of readers becoming surrogate authors to those text, re-birthing them into the world, dying as authors themselves, and giving birth to new readers in the process. As Friedman puts it, “We have come full circle, back to the fabric of a text, this time an intertextual web of critical discourses that are endlessly woven and re-woven. Central to this (intertextual) re-weaving of the critical discourses of intertextuality is the reinsertion of the author, along with some of the biographical and historical methodologies of influence studies, back into the pattern of the fabric” [Friedman. 1991:173].

Obligatory, Optional, Ghost Texts and Spaceballs:

Much like Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1974], Spaceballs [Brooks. 1987] is known, simply, as a parody of the Star Wars franchise, as it stood then. Namely the original trilogy, Star Wars Episode IV – A New Hope [Lucas. 1977], Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back [Kershner. 1980], and Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi [Marquand. 1983]. Spaceballs was far from the first Star Wars parody, as chronicled in Chris Taylor’s How Star Wars Conquered the Universe [Taylor. 2014]. “Like Star Wars itself, the parodies seemed to pretty much die out after the original trilogy ended in 1983. The one notable exception – Mel Brooks’s feature-length Spaceballs in 1987 – seemed outdated on arrival” [Taylor. 2014: 135]. Taylor goes on to quote noted film critic, Roger Ebert’s original 1987 review, “The strangest thing about ‘Spaceballs’ is that it should have been made several years ago, before our appetite for ‘Star Wars’ satires had been completely exhausted. [….] With ‘Spaceballs’, he has made the kind of movie that didn’t really need a Mel Brooks. In bits and pieces, one way or another, this movie already has been made over the last 10 years by countless other satirists” [Ebert. 1987]. Both Taylor and Ebert point out that a number of jokes and gags are recycled from previous parody attempts, “A handful of the jokes, such as the princess’s hair buns turned out to be ear warmers, arrived directly from Hardware Wars” [Taylor. 2014:136]. Given Spaceballs late addition to the selection of Star Wars parodies, it is possible that Brooks gained a lot of his inspiration not only from his own observation of the original trilogy, but a subconscious, or accidental, use of intertextuality from the previous catalogue of Star Wars parody, such as Hardware Wars [Fosselious. 1978], appearances in Mad Magazine [Kurtzman. 1952 – Present], and The Muppet Show [Henson. 1976 – 81]. These unintentional intertextual references “can be caused by similar cultural, historical, and social circumstances. They can be traced back to common formulations, common motifs, or to quotations of a common source text” [Wohrle, et al. 2012:007].

However, what stands it apart from its contemporaries, is Brooks’s use of ‘Optional Intertextuality’. While the film focuses primarily on the Star Wars franchise as it stood then, the film contains noticeable references to other properties, including Ridley Scott’s 1979, science fiction, horror classic, Alien [Scott. 1979], and the Looney Tunes [Avery, Jones, et al. 1930 – 69] short, One Froggy Evening [Jones. 1955]. While these references are fun and interesting for those aware of the original texts, they provide no additional meaning in regards to parodying the Star Wars franchise. The primary audience, or demographic for Star Wars, at the time of its release, may well be aware of the One Froggy Evening [Jones. 1955] cartoon, but the image of the ‘Chestburster’ breaking through John Hurts’ ribs and lungs, as depicted in Alien [Scott. 1979], is far from a desired companion in the Lucas’s Star Wars Universe. In Brooks’s parody of Star Wars, he allows for the material to be skewed to a slightly more adult audience. In this case, Brooks is implementing his own authority over the texts his is intertextualising into his own work. Brooks choice of including these optional intertextual references, may provide evidence for what some practitioners, namely Gray [Gray. 2006], and Kundu [Kundu. 2008] refer to as ‘Ghost Texts’. The concept of introducing outside references, may give new readers an opportunity to recognise and identify other texts, for Brooks to expand the reach of his new text, by applying references to texts outside of the desired subject, to appeal to a broader demographic. The concept of a ‘ghost text’ as described by Gray in Watching with The Simpsons [Gray. 2006], ghost texts “come from the reader, and from other texts the reader has encountered. Resilient in refusing death, any text that we read can potentially live on forever – ageless as Bond and Batman have proven to be – to ‘haunt’ future texts. Ultimately texts stay with us, alive in our memories” [Gray. 2006:26 – 27]. In an artefact, such as a parody film, what would happen if the film itself was the reference, and someone did not understand or are aware of the reference? By allowing texts such as One Froggy Evening [Jones. 1955], Alien [Scott. 1979], The Wizard of OZ [Fleming. 1939], Chinatown [Polanski. 1974], and even some of Brooks previous work, Brooks is allowing these previous texts to ‘haunt’ Spaceballs alongside Star Wars, to hopefully create a better relationship with the readers, and a broader appeal. Each reader viewing Spaceballs, may have a somewhat different relationship to each of the secondary ghosts, refusing to let these secondary ghosts to die.

Genre Subversion and Blazing Saddles:

In contrast to Brooks other films discussed here, Blazing Saddles [Brooks .1974] does not focus on one singular film as it’s subject, but rather Brooks turns his attention to the entire genre of the Western. The origins and definition of Intertextuality come in to play, as instead of relying on parodies of characters or specific plot point, the signs and signifiers of a Western must be examined. The semiotics of a genre. In the case of Blazing Saddles, multiple tropes and clichés of the Western genre are addressed, as well as signifying character traits. The likes of a quick draw, cool and collective gunslinger, often portrayed in the vain of Clint Eastwood in The Man with No Name trilogy (A Fistful of Dollars [Leone. 1964], A Few Dollars More [Leone. 1965], and The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly [Leone. 1966]) or Robert Redford’s Sundance in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid [Hill. 1969], replaced with Gene Wilder’s drunk and comedic ‘Waco Kid’ or simply, Jim. The high ranking member of society, eager to get his hands on land, as seen in A Minute to Pray, a Second to Die (originally titled Un Minuto Per Pregare, Un Istante Per Morire) [Giraldi. 1968], now portrayed as the somewhat inept, sex crazed Governor William J. Le Petomane, played by Brooks himself. By using the signs, signifiers and iconography associated with the Western genre, Brooks can draw upon that wealth, to indicate to the audience what should be expected, to then subvert it in front of them, on screen. As Nick Lacey describes in their book, Narrative and Genre: Key Concepts in Media Studies [Lacey. 2000], “Westerns are very particular in their space (the American frontier) and time (1865 – 90). The Western deals with the conflict between the wilderness and civilisation (a binary opposition), a conflict that occurred on the frontier between the end of the Civil War until both sides of North America were ‘unified’ by the trans-continental railway.” […] “We associate guns and decrepit city streets with the crime genre; iconography in the Western is very exact, possibly because of its very focused time period: the ten-gallon hat, the six-gun, horses, tumbleweed and so on. Iconographic sounds refer both to diegetic and non-diegetic signs. In crime texts, the sound of a police car’s siren (diegetic) is usually endemic just as a Western’s theme music (non-diegetic) is likely to have lush strings, staccato brass and a fast rhythm emphasised by the brass drum” [Lacey. 2000:138].

One convention that Brooks noticeably brings to the forefront, is how the Western genre approaches racism. Given the time period the Western genre places itself into, at the end of the Civil War, “the Indians represent black people who were not considered to be truly American by the racist, southern whites who were opposing the ‘Brown verdict’” [Lacey. 2000:119]. In an example, we can take John Ford’s The Searchers [Ford. 1956], “John Wayne plays an anti-heroic ex-Confederate searching for his teenage niece who has been kidnapped by Indians. When he realizes she has been taken as an Indian wife, he continues searching for her not to rescue her, but to kill her, because she is now racially polluted” [Jacobs. 2015]. “Edwards [Wayne] is a racist and cannot bear the thought of his kin having sex with an Indian who has adopted her as one of his own race” [Lacey. 2000:119]. Brooks plays on this, by not only placing the racist tones to the forefront, but making a black man the sheriff. Something acknowledged at great lengths within the film, by the townspeople, and especially by Bart himself (the newly assigned sheriff, and former slave) when he takes himself hostage, acting as both the town sheriff as authority figure, and black savage in the eyes of the townsfolk. By the films end, the townsfolk welcome him as sheriff, despite his race, subverting the genre expectations in this regard. The films frequent use of derogatory terms can also be seen as a way in which the director draws explicit attention to the nature of racism. It is interesting to note, that the Native American’s portrayed in the film, often used as the stand-ins in Westerns for African American, are seen as wise and sage like, with Mel Brooks himself playing their chief.

Conclusion:

Through the films Spaceballs [Brooks. 1974], Blazing Saddles [Brooks. 1974], and Young Frankenstein [Brooks. 1987], Brooks uses a variety of intertextual techniques in order to implement the parody genre. Through exploring the techniques used and given the nature of the genre, it becomes more than apparent that intertextuality is a key component when constructing a work in the parody mould. In order to construct a narrative that brings to mind specific connotations of an original source, intertextuality is essential. “Because a realist text cannot formally be verified by reference to the ‘real world’, realism must be derived from the interaction between the text’s own internal logic and its reference to other texts, its intertextuality” [Lacey. 2000: 72]. The reliance on these earlier texts, could be seen as a form of postmodernism, the original texts, the modern entertainment, being reformed and shaped into a new artefact, a postmodern work. “Because postmodernism does not deal with the way texts, or any artefacts, refer to reality, postmodern texts can only deal in surfaces. So because we are, for example, strongly influenced by branding when making buying choices, the label becomes more important than the product and the packaging more important than the contents. In media texts this can manifest itself as intertextuality, where texts make meaning through reference to other texts. Take the Cape Feare [Moore. 1993] episode of The Simpsons [Groaning. 1989- Present]: in one short extract, students studying the programme picked out references to: Quentin Tarantino (surf music on Bart’s radio); Edward Scissorhands [Burton. 1990] and Nightmare on Elm Street [Craven. 1984] (Flanders’ trimming and his ‘gloves’); prison movies (Sideshow Bob and his Cellmate); Taxi Driver [Scorsese. 1976] (Sideshow Bob talking to himself in the mirror); Night of the Hunter [Laughton. 1955] (Bob has ‘hate’ written on his knuckles). When students were asked what all this meant, the response was (rightly) one of silence. Postmodernism is not about content, it is only concerned with its own eclecticism” [Lacey. 2000:94]. By parodying an original source, through the use of intertextuality, the original is transformed. It becomes separated from its original authorial intent, and is reborn to another, repeated at infinitum, as each author dies, giving birth to new readers, the original notions and inspirations of a text, become the intertextual ingredients of new, postmodern works.

Bibliography:

  • Alves, T. (2014) The two faces of a myth: the Frankenstein myth and its mythological heritage. Em Tese; 20(2) pp. 131-139.
  • Badalamenti, A. (2006) Why did Mary Shelley write Frankenstein? Journal of Religion and Health, Vol 45, No. 3 (Fall, 2006) pp 419-439.
  • Barthes, R. (1977) The Death of the Author. Images-Music-Text. Pp. 142-148. Hill: New York.
  • Bazerman, C. (2004) Intertextuality: How texts rely on other texts. What writing does and how it does it: An introduction to analysing texts and textual practices, pp. 86-96.
  • Bloom, H. (1973) The Anxiety of Influence. Oxford Press: New York.
  • Bordwell, D. & Thompson, K. (2003) Film Art: An Introduction. McGraw-Hill Company: New York.
  • Brown, T. (2012) Breaking the Fourth Wall: Direct Address in the Cinema. Edinburgh University Press: Edinburgh.
  • Chandler, D. (2014) Intertextuality. [Online] Visual Memory. March 7th. Available from: http://visual-memory.co.uk/daniel/Documents/S4B/sem09.html [Last Accessed: 10/04/2017]
  • Chandler, D. (2014) Introduction. [Online] Visual Memory. March 7th. Available from: http://visual-memory.co.uk/daniel/Documents/S4B/sem01.html [Last Accessed: 10/04/2017]
  • Ebert, R. (1987) Spaceballs. [Online] June 24th. Roger Ebert. Available from: http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/spaceballs=1987 [Last Accessed: 17/04/2017]
  • Eco, Umberto. (1976) A Theory of Semiotics. Indiana University Press: Indiana.
  • Fiske, J. (1989) Moments of television: Neither the text nor the audience. Remote Control: Television, audiences, and cultural power, pp. 56-78.
  • Fitzsimmons, J. (2013) Romantic and Contemporary Poetry: Readings. Romantic and Contemporary Poetry. Chicago University Press: Illinoi.
  • Friedman, S. (1991) Weavings: Intertextuality and the (re)birth of the author. Influence and intertextuality in literary history pp.146-180. University of Wisconsin Press: Madison.
  • Gehring, W. (1999) Parody as Film Genre: “Never Give A Saga an Even Break”. Greenwood Publishing Group: Connecticut.
  • Gray, J. (2006) Watching with The Simpsons: Television, Parody, and Intertextuality. Taylor & Francis: New York.
  • Ivanic, R. (1998) Writing and Identity: The Discoursal Construction of Identity in Academic. John Benjamins Publishing Co: Amsterdam.
  • Jacobs, M. (2015) When Hollywood Westerns Fought Racism. [Online] The Huffington Post. March 12th. Available from: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mw-jacobs/when-hollywood-westerns-fought_b_6854854.html [Last Accessed: 19/04/2017]
  • Kristeva, J. (1980) Desire in Language: A Semiotic Approach to Literature and Art. Columbia UP: New York.
  • Kundu, R. (2008) Intertext: A Study of the Dialogue Between Texts. Sarup & Sons. New Delhi.
  • Kurtzman, H. (1952 – Present) Mad Magazine. [Print] Time Warner: New York.
  • Lacey, N. (2000) Narrative and Genre: Key Concepts in Media Studies. Palgrave Macmillan: New York.
  • Milton, J. (1667) Paradise Lost. Samuel Simmons Publishing: England.
  • Miola, R.S. (2004) Seven types of Intertextuality. Manchester University Press: Manchester.
  • Ott, B. & Bonnstetter, B. (2007) “We’re at Now, Now”: Spaceballs as Parodic Tourism. Southern Communication Journal. Vol, 72, No. 4, Oct-Dec 2007, pp. 309-327.
  • Shelly, M. (1818) Frankenstein; or The Modern Prometheus. Canterbury Classics: San Diego.
  • Whorle, J. (2012) So Many Cross-References! Methodological Reflections on the problem of Intertextual relationships and their significance for redaction critical analysis. Methodological Foundations-Redactional Processes-Historical Insights.
  • Wohrle, J., Nogalski, J., & Albertz, R. (2012) Perspectives on the Formation of the Book of the Tweleve. Walter de Gruyter Publishing: Germany.

Film Bibliography:

  • A Fistful of Dollars, (1964) Film. Directed by Sergio Leone. [Blu-Ray]Constantin Film Produktion. Italy.
  • Alien. (1979) Film. Directed by Ridley Scott. [Blu-Ray] Twentieth Century Fox Productions: UK.
  • A Minute to Pray, A Second to Die (Un Minuto Per Pregare, Un Istante Per Morire) (1968) Film. Directed by Franco Giraldi. [DVD] American Broadcasting Company. Italy.
  • A Nightmare on Elm Street. (1984) Film. Directed by Wes Craven. [Blu-Ray]New Line Cinema: USA.
  • Beetlejuice (1988) Film. Directed by Tim Burton. [Blu-Ray] Geffen Company: USA.
  • Blazing Saddles (1974) Film. Directed by Mel Brooks. [Blu-Ray] Warner Bros Productions: US.
  • Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. (1969) Film. Directed by George Roy Hill. [Blu-Ray] Twentieth Century Fox Production: USA.
  • Cat People (1942) Film. Directed by Jacques Tourneur. [Blu-Ray] RKO Radio Pictures: USA.
  • Chinatown. (1974) Film. Directed by Roman Polanski. [Blu-Ray] Paramount Pictures: USA.
  • Dracula (1931) Film. Directed by Tod Browning. [Blu-ray] Universal Pictures: USA.
  • Edward Scissorhands. (1990) Film. Directed by Tim Burton. [Blu-Ray] Twentieth Century Fox: USA.
  • For a Few Dollars More. (1965) Film. Directed by Sergio Leone. [Blu-Ray] Constantin Film Produktion. Italy.
  • Hardware Wars (1978). Film. Directed by Ernie Fosselius. [VHS] 20th Century Foss Productions: USA.
  • Looney Tunes. (1390 – 69) Television. Created by Tex Avery, Chuck Jones, et al. [DVD] Warner Bros. USA.
  • Men in Black (1997) Film. Directed by Barry Sonnenfeld. [Blu-Ray] Columbia Pictures: USA.
  • Men in Black II (2002) Film. Directed by Barry Sonnenfeld. [Blu-Ray] Columbia Pictures: USA.
  • One Froggy Evening. (1955) Short. Directed by Chuck Jones. [DVD] Warner Bros. USA
  • Prophets of Science Fiction: Mary Shelley. (2011) TV. Directed by Declan Whitebloom. [DVD] November 9th. Scott Free Productions: US.
  • Scary Movie (2000) Film. Directed by Keenan Ivory Wayans. [DVD] Dimension Films: USA.
  • Scream (1996) Film. Directed by Wes Craven. [Blu-Ray] Dimension Films: USA.
  • Spaceballs (1987) Film. Directed by Mel Brooks. [Blu-Ray] Twentieth Century Fox Productions: US.
  • Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope. (1977) Film. Directed by George Lucas. [Blu-Ray] Twentieth Century Fox Productions: US.
  • Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back. (1980) Film. Directed by Irvin Kershner. [Blu-ray] Twentieth Century Fox Productions: US
  • Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi. (1983) Film. Directed by Richard Marquand [Blu-Ray] Twentieth Century Fox Productions: US.
  • Taxi Driver.(1976) Film. Directed by Martin Scorsese. [Blu-ray] Columbia Pictures Corporation: USA.
  • The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. (1966) Film. Directed by Sergio Leone. [Blu-Ray] Constantin Film Produktion. Italy.
  • The Muppet Show. (1976 – 81) Television. Created by Jim Henson. [DVD] The Jim Henson Company: USA
  • The Night of the Hunter. (1955) Film. Directed by Charles Laughton. [Blu-Ray] Paul Gregory Productions: USA.
  • The Searchers. (1956) Film. Directed by John Ford. [Blu-Ray] Warner Bros. USA.
  • The Shining. (1980) Film. Directed by Stanley Kubrick. [Blu-Ray] Warner Bros. Productions: UK.
  • The Simpsons. (1989 – Present) TV. Created by Matt Groening, James L. Brooks, & Sam Simon. [DVD] 20th Century Fox Television: US.
  • The Simpsons: Cape Feare. (1993) TV. Directed by Rich Moore. October 10th. [DVD] 20th Century Fox Television.
  • The Simpsons: Treehouse of Horror. (1990) TV. Directed by Wesley Archer, Rich Moore, & David Silverman. October 25th. [DVD] 20th Century Fox Television: US.
  • The Simpsons: Treehouse of Horror V. (1994) TV. Directed by Jim Reardon. October 30th. [DVD] 20th Century Fox Television: US.
  • The Wizard of Oz. (1939) Film. Directed by Victor Fleming. [Blu-Ray] Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer: USA
  • Young Frankenstein. (1974) Film. Directed by Mel Brooks. [Blu-Ray] Gruskoff/Venture Films: USA.

Journalism and The Dark Knight Returns

It may not instantly come to mind, but journalism runs deep through the worlds of superhero comics. Comics first superhero, Superman, lives his alter ego as Clark Kent, mild-mannered reporter for the Daily Planet. Superman’s love interest, the wonderful Lois Lane, famously states in the 1978s Superman: The Movie, that “a good reporter doesn’t get good stories, a good reporter makes them great.” Hop across to the Marvel universe, and you have the likes of Spider-Man (Peter Parker), The Green Goblin (Norman Osborne), Ben Urich, J. Jonah Jameson, and Silk (Cindy Moon), all have prominent ties to either The Daily Bugle, or Fact Channel News.

Both the Daily Planet, originally named the Daily Star until the 1940s radio show starring Bud Collyer, and the Daily Bugle, are mainstays of their respective universes. It’s hard to separate their existence from their respective characters. Each provides a central role in their lives. Clark Kent becomes a reporter for one of the biggest newspapers around, The Daily Planet, in order to stay up to date with the latest information around the world, and see when he is needed most. Peter Parker, as a teenager, worked freelance selling photos of his alter ego, Spider-Man, to the Daily Bugle for a little extra money to support himself and his Aunt May during high school and college. Cindy Moon, a fairly recent character to the Marvel Universe, taking on the role of Silk, joins Fast Channel News, under J. Jonah Jameson, the former editor in chief of The Daily Bugle, in order to learn more about the world, after being locked away for 13 years, and to help track down her family. Aside from instances such as Civil War, where the situation is used as commentary on real life events, such as the patriot act, news media is used as a means for our heroes to look upon the rest of the world, and examine it, if anything, it denotes how they stand apart from the rest, watching the rest of humanity from afar, and intervening when they see fit.

However, when it comes to Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns, it’s interesting to see that the news media takes on a different position. Rather than giving the superhero a look at the world around him, the news media acts as the world commenting on Batman himself. The effect his return has, and how the world reacted to his initial disappearance. As Kofoes states in his paper, Breaking the Frame, “The media can only react to his presence, shaping the interpretation but not the form his actions take”. The news reports act more for us, then they do for Batman, we learn just how long Batman has been in retirement, the war in Corto Maltese, and the inactivity of Batman’s previous rogue gallery. Interestingly, It’s Superman that provides the most interesting commentary on how the news features in The Dark Knight Returns. Stating, “They were considering their options and you were probably still laughing when we came to terms. I gave them my obedience and my invisibility. They gave me a license and let me live. No I didn’t like it. But I get to save lives… and the media stays quiet. But now the storm is growing again—they hunt us down again—because of you”. It’s an interesting parallel for Superman to be the one to comment on the media hunting them down, the use of words, paints the news media as just as dangerous as the likes of The Mutants or The Joker. Even when the story puts complete focus on the news stories, when trying to compare the Pro-Batman side, with the Anti-Batman camp, the focus still paints Batman in a negative light.

Miller’s grim and gritty view of a future Batman echoes through multiple levels. But the stories primary method of world building, the news media, breaks away from how it is traditionally seen in mainstream comics. A feature previously used to help our heroes keep an eye on the world at large, becomes just as big a threat, if not greater, than The Joker himself.

Cinema Reels, and Four Colour Panels [Academic paper]

How Film and Television industries have used Comic Books to augment their narratives through Transmedia Storytelling.

Abstract

This paper seeks to discuss how the film and television industries are using the comic book medium for the purpose of transmedia storytelling. This paper uses franchises such as The Matrix, The X-Files, and Star Wars as examples of transmedia storytelling to various degrees of success, and exploring why the choice to use comic books was made, in reflection to the time of inception. The paper also provides a distinction between adapting a franchise to the comic book medium and expanding the narrative to include it.

Introduction

As forms of media have evolved, they have provided us with “multiple models for exploration” [McLuhan & Fiore, 1967: 69], that lead to various possibilities in the realm of storytelling. With multiple media available for creators to work in, comes an opportunity to expand a narrative through the practice of transmedia storytelling, allowing a story to be told across a multitude of platforms, in contrast to the practice of adaptation which takes a story from one medium and retells it through another [Hutcheon, 2006]. A creative and attractive use of transmedia can become deeply immersive for an audience, and in many cases the consumers can see that what is available through just one medium as not enough, thereby creating a demand for more [Scolari, Beretti & Freeman, 2014: 2]. In an early example of fan outcry [Lycett, 2011], Arthur Conan Doyle was persuaded to bring his most iconic character, Sherlock Holmes, back from the dead after 16 years, in The Adventure of the Empty House [Doyle, 1903]. With the forming of a transmedia franchise, “the audience becomes a participant” [McLuhan & Fiore, 1967: 101], with the ability to pick and choose what they wish to see in a particular medium and influence what is produced, unlike an adapted story that simply offers the same story retold in a different format [Jenkins, 2006]. Despite the term ‘transmedia storytelling’ only being coined in 2003 by Henry Jenkins, examples of the practice have existed far longer. The format can find its roots in the Japanese practice of ‘Media Mix’ culture [Jenkins, 2006], with Osamu Tezuka’s Tetsuwan Atomu [Tezuka, 1952 – 1968] (known as Astro Boy in the West) being cited as one of its first examples [Steinberg, 2012] [Schodt, 2007].

For a transmedia franchise to be successful, it must offer the consumer choice. The audience must be able to consume any piece of the franchise in any order, enjoy a coherent story and have the choice to dive in further, not the obligation [Weaver, 2013: 44]. The longer the audience wish to remain in that world, the greater the franchise’s perceived worth. Henry Jenkins has described transmedia storytelling, most simply as being “the art of world building” [Jenkins, 2006: 24]. While a film or television project could be said to already inhabit this principle, the use of transmedia storytelling opens “a new door within the great realm” [Manard, 2015: 9] can be reached, creating a universe rather than just a world. These vast universes allow an audience the opportunity to explore at their leisure, and the choice of how much they are “willing to discover” [Weaver, 2013: 44].

A strong example of transmedia storytelling in action, is that of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) [Faveru, 2008] (the collection term given to the current selection of Marvel films) from Marvel Entertainment, now a subsidiary of Disney since 2009 [Clarke, 2009]. Despite the MCU beginning as adaptations of Marvel properties, dating back as far as 1941’s Captain America #1 [Simon & Kirby, 1941], with careful planning and production [Howe, 2012] Marvel declared to its global audience that it is on the front line of transmedia implementation” [Menard, 2015: 12], announcing that its multiple films, television series structured universe. Hollywood’s adoption of the comic book medium has long existed even before the MCU, with early examples including Adventures of Captain Marvel [English & Witney, 1941] and the Fleisher Studio Superman cartoons [Fleisher, 1941].

Comic books can and have provided the opportunity to discuss a wide and varied range of subject matters, “as a form that can both reveal the mindset and the thinking of its characters and also has a robust language for action” [Dowd, 2015: 204]. While the superhero genre is the most prominent in the comic book medium, there have been several points in history where romance and horror comics have outsold their superhero counterparts, particularly after the Second World War [Howe, 2012]. Despite the consensus that comic books are solely restricted to superhero and action adventure subjects, perpetuated with big screen adaptations such as Kingsman: The Secret Service [Vaughn, 2014] and The Dark Knight [Nolan, 2008], it is important to remember their versatility, that the message should never be mistaken for the messenger [McCloud, 1994: 6]. The genre possibilities for comics are just as open and broad as those available to film or television. Comics can, and have, explored multiple genres, characters and themes, including real world re-enactments, such as Maus [Spiegleman, 1991], and sweeping space dramas, including The Ballad of Halo Jones [Moore & Gibson, 1984]. Some film and television shows are adaptations themselves of properties that may not appear to be comic book at first glance, such as Blue is the Warmest Colour [Kechiche, 2013] and The Diary of a Teenage Girl [Heller, 2015], strengthening the proof of the comic book mediums versatility.

Despite the wide variety of choice genre-wise, the most common genres used for adaptation and transmedia purposes, are science fiction and fantasy. The science fiction genre in particular is one that never fades. “it may pass out of fashion for a time, only to return in updated garb” [Bordwell & Thompson, 2004: 116]. The science fiction and fantasy genres are already open to world building, thanks to their origins as evolutions from fantastic voyage tales [Haley, 2014: 8], and so it is natural that they would be the most frequently experimented with in the transmedia practice. However the idea of a ‘tie-in’ comic may be seen in some circles as relatively unremarkable and of little interest to any other than “die-hard fan boys looking to fill the gaps between TV seasons” [Fingeroth, 2008: 269]. Nevertheless, they can also be seen as examples of what Henry Jenkins refers to as “meta-text” [Jenkins, 1992], offering readers a chance to experience the characters and hallmarks of the series outside of the screen [Pillai, 2003: 102]. While there are numerous examples of transmedia storytelling in action, three notable entries for various reasons are that of Star Wars [Lucas, 1977], The X-Files [Carter, 1993 – 2016], and The Matrix [Wachowskis, 1999] franchises.

Analysis

The Star Wars franchise provides both an early and prime example of transmedia practice at work. When Star Wars [Lucas, 1977] was in the process of being released, it became imperative that attention was drawn to the project through other media, due to the distributor and executives’ lack of faith in the project [Haley, 2014]. It was decided that attracting early attention through comic books would be an ideal choice [Taylor, 2015: 160], and approaching Marvel Comics’ Stan Lee, and later Roy Thomas, with the proposal for a six issue adaptation, distributed so the third issue would be available before the film opened [Howe, 2012: 193]. This culminated in a 107 issue run, spanning all three films, the time in-between, and the aftermath [Taylor, 2015: 280 – 281] [Thomas, et. al., 1977 – 1986]. At the point of issue 7, the comics transitioned from an adaptation to a transmedia franchise. With the phenomenal success of the first film, the Star Wars comic became some of the first since the Batman [Dozer, Finger & Semple Jr., 1966 – 1968] craze of 1966 to sell over a million issues, “the Star Wars adaptation brought a whole new interest to comics in a decade that was for the most part a slow one” [Weaver, 2013: 153], thus cementing Star Wars as a prime transmedia franchise early on in its lifetime. It is worth noting that at the time, the printed comics were the only way to re-experience the Star Wars films without returning to the cinema until their eventual home release, leading to the comics’ high sale rate.

Marvel used this opportunity to expand the franchise’s lore through the use of its characters, mythology and settings, and while the franchise was still young, provided a number of baselines for later entries. With the constraints of writing around both Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back [Kersher, 1980] and Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi [Marquand, 1983], the comic was able to develop and explore details that the films could not explore, due to time or budget restraints. Focusing and developing on stories of the Rebels dodging the Empire (and thus the surrounding of the movies)”, fighting “one off aliens, rogue imperial Barons and Bounty Hunters”, with the comics having to “wax and wane between adapting a new movie and telling original stories” [Whitbrock, 2015]. Through the adapted and expanded work, the comics were able to “keep that prior work alive, giving it an afterlife” [Hutcheon, 2006: 176], thus retaining interest in the property during the absences between films. The impact the original Marvel run had can still be seen, not only in the franchise’s comic book successors, but also in the most recent entry, Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens [Abrams, 2015], and most notably in its depiction of a looming threat arising after the Empire falls. The initial Marvel run is one of the first entries in what is referred to as The Expanded Universe (the collective term given in the Star Wars franchise [Taylor, 2015]), crossing multiple films, comic books, novels (such as Heir of the Empire [Zahn, 1991]), specials, cartoons, and video games (including Star Wars: The Force Unleashed [Lucas Arts, 2008]) [Taylor, 2015] [Haley, 2014], essentially, the definition of a transmedia franchise.

By 1987, Marvel had ended its run on the franchise, “merchandising came to a halt. By 1985, Star Wars fever had largely subsided” [Bowen, 2005: xi]. During the beginning of the 1990s, Dark Horse Comics had come to acquire the license and with Star Wars: Dark Empire [Veitch, 1991 – 1992], they proved themselves more than capable of maintaining the Expanded Universe as well as breathing new life into the franchise by reigniting interest [Taylor, 2015]. Many have come to hold the Dark Horse entries in high regard, able to stand “head to head with the classic films” [Saacedra, 2015] in regards to quality. Despite the casual film fan remaining largely ignorant of the Expanded Universe, or having little to no desire to dive into the material, it provided the franchise with a far greater level of depth than the films could alone. With the acquisition of Lucas Arts by Disney in 2012 [Smith, 2012], the previously built Expanded Universe became ‘non-canon’. However, Disney understood just how vital transmedia is to the Star Wars franchise and used its previous acquisition of Marvel [Clarke, 2009] to explore this universe once again, in a way that is comparable to Marvel’s earlier excursions. While each form of media provides a coherent story and would allude to or reference the other, knowledge of every form was not a necessity for enjoyment, providing the audience with the choice of what they are willing to explore.

In the case of The X-Files [Carter, 1993 – 2016], the franchise’s use of transmedia provides a contrast to that of Star Wars in their choice of a serio-episodic structure in their comic books, a similar structure to their television series’ own format. This allowed for instalments to be presented or shown in “an almost random presentation” [Mittell, 2006]. With an episodic or serio-episodic structure in place when planning a transmedia world, continuity and timeline become less of an issue. The episodic or serio-episodic structure allows for events and characters to be created and stories to be told and placed at any point in the franchise, while still remaining in continuity. This structure enables the comic books to focus on a consistency of characters and mythology, while experimenting with settings and events. In the comic industry these are usually referred to as “‘done in one’ adventures, something the Golden and Silver ages [1935 – 1956 and 1956 – 1970 respectively [Levitz, 2013]] used to great effect” [Weaver, 2013: 90]. The X-Files lends itself to the structure remarkably well, containing various revisited storylines across multiple series and films (known as the Mythology episodes) and a multitude of standalone stories. With this familiar set up already in place, it allows fans of the series to easily move over to the comic and for those introduced to The X-Files through comics to enjoy the series in a similar storytelling format. “The episodic structure makes much more use of the audience’s goodwill towards the characters, as you visit them when all is normal – not when they’re facing certain death” [Weaver, 2013: 90], thereby creating a deeper connection between the audience and the characters. The X-Files franchise was consciously built to be a cult series, “to attract the fan consumer market” [Pillai, 2013: 106]. With this cult status and fan base in place, expanding the narrative to new forms of media becomes a more attractive concept, as a dedicated fan base is ready to consume most media related to that franchise.

With the television series being considered by many as the main continuity, the prospect of moving between screen and print may appear to cheapen the printed stories’ perceived worth in the eyes of consumers. This provides the challenge of proving the comics’ worth, that while the “stapled pages of words and pictures may seem materially and culturally flimsy” [Pillai, 2013: 102], they are, just as film can be, “a vessel which can hold any number of ideas” [McCloud, 1994: 108]. In the case of The X-Files, the choice was made to bring a form of authorial ownership to the comics by reproducing the “distinctive font of the brand logo and a ‘created by Chris Carter’ banner” [Pillai, 2013: 108] to the cover and content. This decision ultimately brought a sense of worth to the comics that they may not have achieved otherwise. In addition to the seeming lack of authorship that ‘tie-in’ comics may display in relationship to their ‘parent’ medium, the difficulty also arises as to how the comic portray key characters. While this is a problem not entirely unique to The X-Files franchise, as most transmedia franchises that feature an illustrated medium will encounter it at some stage, the illustrated representations of characters are a key component in the original Topps comics’ success. A large part of a character’s identity is not only developed through the script , but through the actors’ or actresses’ interpretation of them. The original Topps line of comics [Petrucha, et. al., 1995 – 1998] would most noticeably attempt to side step the limitation, by providing photographic covers for each of the comics. However, this did not solve the initial problem, as the characters depicted in the story are clearly hand drawn caricatures. While many would cite Gillian Anderson’s physical performance as Scully as being the defining element of the character, “her gesture and her voice” are distinctly Andersons, “in contrast, comics lack motion” [Pillai, 2013: 109], the artist must in his or her own way, conjure a representation of not only the characters’ likeness but their behaviour and mannerisms in the form of static images. A notable artist in the original line of Topps comics, is Charlie Adlard, who used his interpretation of the character as “an avatar, limited in its capacity to evoke Gillian Anderson but freed to expand upon the representational range of Scully”. “Adlard developed conventions of representing Scully that depicted the character’s physicality and costuming without imitating Anderson’s likeness” [Pillai, 2013: 109], thereby using the examples set by the actors as a framework in which to build upon, without betraying the essence or nature of the character.

In a similar vein to that of the Star Wars franchise, The X-Files has seen revival in both its comic incarnation and in its ‘parent’ medium. With a line of comics from publisher IDW [Harris, 2013 – 2015], continuing the series past its initial cancelation and subsequent film, The X-Files: I Want to Believe [Carter, 2008], The X-Files was able to live on through a medium where it already had a foot-hold. According to The X-Files: Season 10 [Harris, 2013 – 2015] and The X-Files: Season 11 [Harris 2015 – 2016] comic writer, Joe Harris, deciding to continue the series as a comic proves the “awesome crossover appeal and potential this franchise brings to the publishing, and the industry” [Allair, 2015]. Due to the franchise’s cult following, many long time fans who do not read comics have picked the franchise up in the comic book medium, in order to dive back into the series [Allair, 2015]. With the 2016 return of The X-Files to television, the creator Chris Carter wanted to once again tap into the cult fan base, in the same way the comics did, stating “this is for them” [Topel, 2016]. The fan base for the franchise is what has kept the series alive, sustained by both the Topps and IDW comics until its much anticipated television return.

In a contrast to both The X-Files [Carter, 1993 – 2016] and Star Wars [Lucas, 1977], The Matrix [Wachowskis, 1999] franchise provides a stark warning as to what can happen when the core objective of transmedia storytelling is ignored: choice. A transmedia franchise must “offer choice” [Weaver, 2013: 36] to be successful. To discard this concept, is essentially to do damage to the franchise as a whole. Though its use of film, anime, comic books and games, may portray The Matrix franchise as a prime transmedia example, its execution was predicted on the audience having already consumed the previous media in the correct order, “no film franchise has ever made such demands of its consumers” [Jenkins, 2006: 94]. When considering only the sequel films, events and characters are presented with no explanations assuming “we have almost complete mastery over its complex mythology and ever-expanding cast of secondary characters” [Jenkins, 2006: 96], a mistake that is carried over to other related material.

As The Matrix was being released internationally, the Wachowskis planned how a complete universe and story could be told, through multiple media [Oreck, 2003]. Despite the plan to display their universe through many anime, comics, films and video games, its execution “expected its audience to seek out every single piece” [Weaver, 2013: 36], that in order to “understand the complexity of the movie’s Matrix, one needed to purchase additional media” [Proffitt, Tchoi & McAlister, 2007: 246]. In the case of the second film, The Matrix Reloaded [Wachowskis, 2003], there is no explanation as to what the matrix is, why the main characters are important or why the audience should care, before more important details concerning the plot are introduced. Secondary, seemingly one off characters, such as ‘Kid‘, are introduced with no explanation of their significance, other than those given in supplementary material, including Kid’s Story [Watanabe, 2003]. While this would usually be an ideal practice if you are attempting to augment your storytelling world with supplementary material, it is done so often throughout both The Matrix Reloaded and The Matrix Revolution [Wachowskis, 2003] that any member of the audience that had not sought out, or was possibly unaware of the supplementary material, was left without numerous incidents and plot points explained. The fault with this execution, is that the creators failed to provide one coherent story in just one medium, “its reliance on continuing plot lines in multiple media forms relegated it to notable failure. It was expectantly transmedia” [Weaver, 2013: 36]. The franchise’s reliance on multiple media to fill in gaps, robbed the audience of the choice to dive in further, forcing them either to give up on the story or to switch to new media completely.

The creators’ choice in regards to how they expand their narrative, heavily reflects their own inspirations and influences. It has been noted several times by the Wachowskis that they drew greatly from anime, such as Akira [Otomo, 1988] and Ghost in the Shell [Oshii, 1995] [Oreck, 2003], as well as several comic books, including Grant Morrison’s The Invisibles [Morrison, 1994 – 2000]. Morrison himself has stated the, “so much of The Matrix is plot by plot, detail by detail, image by image, lifted from Invisibles so there shouldn’t be much controversy” [Epstein, 2005]. With this wealth of inspiration through various media, the directors’ choice to use these to their advantage, becomes a natural evolution to the story. Anime shorts such as The Second Renaissance [Maeda, 2003], which portrays the overthrowing of humanity that leads to the events of the films, and The Final Flight of the Osiris [Jones, 2003], documents the final mission of the Osiris crew as told by the character Nyrobi in The Matrix Revolution. Also comic books such as A Life Less Empty [McKeever, 2003], which uses a new character to contrast the possible life Neo would have led had he chosen the blue pill, and Déjà Vu [Chadwick, 2004], focused on a couple still trapped in the Matrix catching glimpses of the ‘real world’ in their dreams. Despite the volume and talent behind the comics however, they are the least known and distributed of the available media, while also being the franchise’s best case for transmedia in action. The stories told through the comics are centred around background characters and events, providing readers with a connection to the world around the main characters building a greater mythology for the franchise.

Possibly the greatest artefact The Matrix has produced for an example of transmedia done correctly, is the short comic Bits and Pieces of Information [Wachowskis & Darrow, 2003]. Though the comic consists of only eight pages, it requires no previous knowledge of the franchise and provides a look at the catalyst of the franchise’s history. The events shown are presented as everyday occurrences, such as ‘B116ER’s achievement as the first robot to kill a human, that requires no knowledge of what came before or after but is reflected in the story of The Second Renaissance and become the originating plot point for The Matrix films. “The comic introduced the pivotal figure of B116ER”, “The Second Renaissance builds upon Bits and Pieces of Information” [Jenkins, 2006: 118] which both form the backbone for the first film. Though the manner in which The Matrix attempted transmedia storytelling lacked an understanding of choice, it is “a flawed experiment, an interesting failure, but that its flaws did not detract from the significance of what it tried to accomplish” [Jenkins, 2006: 97].

Conclusion

Transmedia storytelling has been used by numerous franchises to both a phenomenal degree of success and notable failure, with The X-Files, Star Wars, and The Matrix barely scratching the surface of what is available to explore. The film and television industries embrace of the comic book medium has allowed both industries the opportunity to expand their narrative in a way neither format could achieve on their own, additionally prolonging a franchise’s life span by keeping the narrative alive, “giving it an afterlife it would never have had otherwise” [Hutcheon, 2006: 176]. The comic book format, due to its versatility can and has been used not only to expand an ongoing narrative, but to reawaken long dormant properties and reintroduce them to their original audience, and a wider demographic that may have missed the initial release, with a lower cost of entry and less risk then a multi-million dollar film or television project. “Unlike film, television and games”, comics give the “possibility for a creator from outside the mainstream industry to reach a mass audience” [Dowd, 2015: 204], and for creators to experiment with the narrative alongside the audience feedback, providing a more open dialogue between, creators, producers and fans. With this free exchange, the audience can feel as though they are taking a far more active role as well as that of an explorer, able to navigate as they wish and influence the course set before them. The future of transmedia storytelling, not only on the Imax enabled surround sound screens but also in the four colour pages, will be forged as a collaboration between fan and producer, [Weaver, 2013: 45] creating broad new horizons towards which the audience can choose to set sail.

Bibliography

  • Abrams, J.J. (2015) Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens. [Blu-ray] Lucas Films. Bad Robot Productions. Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures.
  • Allair, M. (2015) Interview with Joe Harris, The X-Files Season 10 and the revival [Online] Den of Geek. 5th May. Available from: http://www.denofgeek.us/books-comics/the-x-files/245810/the-x-files-joe-harris-talks-x-files-season-10-and-the-revival. [Last Accessed: 03/12/2015]
  • Blichert, F. (2014) The Expanded ‘verse: Serialised Transmedia in Firefly/Serenity. Carleton University. Ontario.
  • Bordwell, D. Thompson, K. (2004) Film Art: An Introduction. McGraw-Hill Companies Ltd. New York.
  • Bourdaa, M. (2013) Following the Pattern: The Creation of an Encyclopaedic Universe With Transmedia Storytelling. Oxford University Press. Oxford.
  • Briers, M. (2015) Licensed Games – Negative Stigma and Facing an Uphill Battle. [Online] PlayStation Life Style. 29th July. Available from: http://www.playstationlifestyle.net/2015/07/29/licensed-games-star-wars-battlefront/#/slide/1 [Last Accessed: 29/01/2016].
  • Briggs, A. Burke, P. (2009) A Social History of the Media. From Gutenberg to the Internet. Polity Press. Cambridge.
  • Brownie, B. Graydon, D. (2015) The Superhero Costume. Identity and Disguise in Fact and Fiction. Bloomsbury Academic. Bloomsbury Publishing PLC. London.
  • Brownstein, C. Eisner/Miller. Interview conducted by Charles Brownstein” (Milwaukie: Dark Horse, 2005), p.15.
  • Carter, C. (1993 – 2016) The X-Files.[Blu-ray] Ten Thirteen Productions. 20th Century Fox Television.
  • Carter, C. (2008) The X-Files: I Want to Believe. [Blu-ray] Ten Thirteen Productions. 20th Century Fox Film Corporation.
  • Chadwick, P. (2004) Déjà Vu. Burlyman Entertainment Brooklyn.
  • Chandler, D. (2007) Semiotics: The Basics. Rotledge. London.
  • Chute, H. (2008) Comics as Literature? Reading Graphic Narrative. Modern Language Association.
  • Clarke, A. (2009) Disney Buys Marvel Entertainment [Online] The Guardian. 31st August. Available from: http://www.theguardian.com/business/2009/aug/31/disney-marvel-buy-out [Last Accessed: 22/01/2016]
  • Daniels, L. (1991) Marvel. Five Fabulous Decades of the World’s Greatest Comics Marvel Entertainment Group, Inc. Harry N. Adams, Incorporated. New York.
  • Dietsch, T. (2015) Joe Harris takes Mulder on the run in IDW’s X-Files: Season 11. [Online] Comic Book Resources. 18th June. Available from: http://www.comicbookresources.com/article/joe-harris-takes-mulder-on-the-run-in-idws-x-files-season-11 [Last Accessed: 17/01/2016]
  • Dowd, T. (2015) Transmedia: One Story – Many Media. CRC Press.
  • Doyle, A C. (1903) The Adventure of the Empty House. George Newnes Ltd. London.
  • Dozier, W. Finger, B. Semple Jr., L. (1966 – 1968) Batman [Blu-ray] Greenway Productions. 20th Century Fox Television.
  • English, J. Whitney, W. (1941) Adventures of Captain Marvel. [Television] Republic Pictures.
  • Epstein, D. (2005) Grant Morrison. [Online] Suicide Girls. 27th February. Available from: https://suicidegirls.com/girls/anderswolleck/blog/2679166/grant-morrison/ [Last Accessed: 31/01/2016]
  • Favreau, J. (2008) Iron Man [Blu-ray]. Paramount Pictures. Marvel Enterprises, Marvel Studios.
  • Fingeroth, D. (2008) The Rough Guide to Graphic Novels. London: Rough Guides.
  • Fleisher, D. (1941) Superman [Blu-ray]. Fleisher Studios.
  • Gere, C. (2002) Digital Culture. Reaktion Books. London.
  • Glacomoleedotcom. (2015) X-Files COmics Unified. [Online] Kinja. 4th March. Available from: gleelee.kinja.com/x-files-comics-unified-1695512817 [Last Accessed: 17/01/2016]
  • Gordon, I. (1998) Comic Strips and Consumer Culture 1890 – 1945. Washington Smithsonian Institute Press.
  • Gresh, L. Weinberg, R. (2002) The Science of Superheroes. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Hoboken. New Jersey.
  • Hadas, L. (2014) Authorship and Authenticity in the Transmedia Brand: The Case of Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. University of Northampton, UK.
  • Haley, G. (2014) Sci-Fi Chronicles. A Visual History of the Galaxy’s Greatest Science Fiction Quintessence Editions Ltd. London.
  • Harris, J. et. al. (2013 – 2015) The X-Files: Season 10 IDW Publishing. San Diego. California.
  • Harris, J. et. al. (2015 – 2016) The X-Files: Season 11 IDW Publishing. San Diego. California.
  • Heller, M. (2015) The Diary of a Teenage Girl. [Blu-ray]. Caviar Films. Cold Iron Pictures.
  • Howe, S. (2012) Marvel Comics: The Untold Story. Harper Collins: London.
  • Hutcheon, L. (2006) A Theory of Adaptation. New York. Routledge.
  • Jenkins, H. (1992) Textual Poachers: Television Fans and Participatory Culture. Routledge. London.
  • Jenkins, H. (2003) Transmedia Storytelling. Moving Characters from Books to Video Games can make them Stronger and more Compelling, [Online] MIT Technology Review. 15th January. Available from: http://www.technologyreview.com/news/401760/transmedia-storytelling/ [Last Accessed: 23/01/2016].
  • Jenkins, H. (2006) The Cultural Logic of Media Convergence. Saga Publications. Thousand Oak. California.
  • Jenkins, H. (2006) Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide. USA. NYU Press.
  • Johnson, C. (2005) Telefantasy London. BFI.
  • Jones, A. (2003) Final Flight of the Osiris. [DVD] Square USA, Inc. Warner Home Video.
  • Kakalios, J. (2010) The Physics of Superheroes. Duckworth Overlook. London.
  • Kamen, M. (2015) The Lost Riches of Star Wars’ Expanded Universe. [Online] Wired. 26th November. Available from: http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2015-11/26/star-wars-expanded-universe-best [Last Accessed: 13/01/2016]
  • Kechiche, A. (2013) Blue Is the Warmest Colour. [Blu-ray]. Quat’sous Films. France 2 Cinema.
  • Kermode, M. (2011) The Good, The Bad and the Multiplex. What’s Wrong with Modern Movies? Random House Books. London.
  • Kershner, I. (1980) Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back Lucas Film. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation.
  • Lavery, D. Hague, A. Cartwright, M. (1996) Generation X: The X-Files and the Cultural Moment. Deny All Knowledge: Reading the X-Files, Faber & Faber, pp.1-21.
  • Lee, S. Kirby, J. (1961) The Fantastic Four #1 Marvel Comics. Marvel Entertainment. New York.
  • Lehman-Wilzig, S. Cohen-Avigdor, N. (2004) The Natural Life Cycle of Media Evolution Inter-Media Struggle for Survival in the Internet Age. New Media & Society, pp707 – 730.
  • Levitz, P. (2013) The Golden Age of DC Comics 1935 – 1956. Taschen, Cologne.
  • Long, G. (2007). Transmedia Storytelling. Business, Aesthetics and Production at the Jim Henson Company. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Massachusetts.
  • Loredo, J. (2012) I Believe in Sherlock Holmes: Sherlockian Fandom, Then & Now. University of North Texas. USA.
  • Lucas Arts. (2008) Star Wars: The Force Unleashed. [PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3, Wii, Xbox 360]. Lucas Arts.
  • Lucas, G. (1977) Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope. [Blu-ray] Lucas Film. Twentieth Century Fox.
  • Lycett, A. (2011) Conan Doyle: The Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes. Hachette UK.
  • Maeda, M. (2003) The Second Renaissance Part I [DVD] Studio 4C. Warner Home Video.
  • Maeda, M. (2003) The Second Renaissance Part II [DVD] Studio 4C. Warner Home Video.
  • Mathijs, E. Mendik, X. (2007) The Cult Film Reader. McGraw-Hill Education. UK.
  • Manak, D. et. al. (1985 – 1987) Ewoks. Marvel COmics. New York.
  • Manak, D. Carragone, G. (1986 – 1987) Star Wars Droids. Marvel Comics. New York.
  • Marquand, R. (1983) Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi. Lucas Film. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation.
  • McCloud, S. (1994) Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. New York: Harper Perennial.
  • McCool, B. (2015) Alan Moor’s Star Wars Episode I: The Pandora Effect. [Online] Tech Times. 11th November. Available from: http://www.techtimes.com/articles/105206/20151111/alan-moores-star-wars-episode-pandora-effect.html [Last Accessed: 13/01/2016]
  • McKeever, T. (2003) A Life Less Empty. Burlyman Entertainment. Brooklyn.
  • McLuhan, M. Fiore, Q. (1967) The Medium is the Massage. Penguin Books. London.
  • McLuhan, M. Fiore, Q. (1967) The Medium is the Message New York, 123.
  • Menard, D. (2013) Entertainment Assembled: The Marvel Cinematic Universe, A Case Study in Transmedia. Liberty University. USA.
  • Mittell, J. (2006) Narrative Complexity in Contemporary American Television. University of Texas. Austin.
  • Moloney, K. (2011) The Matrix [Online] Transmedia Journalism. 30th July. Available from: transmediajournalism.org/tag/the-matrix/ [Last Accessed: 18/01/2016]
  • Moloney, K. (2011) Porting Transmedia Storytelling to Journalism. University of Denver. Colorado.
  • Moore, A. Gibson, I. (1984) The Ballad of Halo Jones. Rebellion Developments. 2000AD. Oxford.
  • Morrison, G. (2011) Supergods: Our World in the age of the Superhero. London. Jonathan Cape Publication.
  • Morrison, G. (1994 – 2000) The Invisibles. Vertigo. New York City.
  • Nolan, C. (2008) The Dark Knight. [Blu-ray] Warner Bros. Legendary Pictures. Syncopy.
  • O’Neil, T. (2015) A Really Long Time ago, Marvel played fast and loose with Star Wars. [Online] AV Club. 21st November. Available from: http://www.avclub.com/article/really-long-time-ago-marvel-played-fast-and-loose–228177 [Last Accessed: 13/01/2016]
  • Oreck, J. (2003) Scrolls to Screen: A Brief History and Culture of Anime. [DVD] Warner Home Video. Warner Home Video.
  • Osamu, T. (1952 – 1968) Tetsuwan Atomu. Shonen Kobunsha. Kodansha. Tokyo.
  • Oshii, M. (1995) Ghost in the Shell. [Blu-ray] Bandai Visual Company. Kodansha. Production I.G.
  • Otomo, K. (1988) Akira. [Blu-ray]. TMS Entertainment. Akira Committee Company Ltd.
  • Palmer, L. (2013) What the Matrix: Revolutions teaches us about Hollywood’s Past Ten Years. [Online] Film School Rejects. 5th November. Available from: filmschoolrejects.com/features/what-the-matrix-revolutions-teaches-us-about-hollywood.php [Last Accessed: 18/01/2016]
  • Parikka, J. (2012) What is Media Archaeology? Polity Press. Cambridge.
  • Petrucha, S. et. al. (1995 – 1998) The X-Files. Topps Comics. Topps Company, Inc. Manhattan.
  • Pilcher, T. Brooks, B. (2005) The Essential Guide to World Comics. Chrysalis Books Group plc. London.
  • Pillai, N. (2013) What am I Looking at Mulder? Licensed comics and the freedom of transmedia storytelling. Liverpool University Press. Liverpool.
  • Pillai, N. (2011) The Batman Adventures: Rendering the comic page. The Comic Grid. Available from: http://www.comicsgrid.com/2011/09/page-batman-adventures. [Last Accessed: 09/12/15]
  • Proffitt, J. M., Tchoi, D. Y., McAliister, M. P. (2007) Plugged Back into The Matrix, The Intertextual Flow of Corporate Media Commodities. Journal of Communication Inquiry, 31 (3), pp. 239 – 254.
  • Ross, E. (2015) Filmish: A Graphic Journey Through Film. Self Made Hero. London.
  • Rouse, I. (2015) Marvel’s Star Wars comics make the franchise better. [Online] The Impact. 2nd April. Available from: theimpactnews.com/item-we-barely-use/retired-colomists/isaac-has-issues/2015/04/02/marvels [Last Accessed: 13/01/2016]
  • Saavedra, J. (2015) Star Wars: the 13 greatest Dark Horse comic stories. [Online] Den of Geek. 4th January. Available from: http://www.denofgeek.us/books-comic/star-wars/231894/star-wars-the-13-greatest-dark-horse-comic-stories [Last Accessed: 13/01/2016]
  • Schodt, F. (2007) The Astro Boy Essays. Osamu Tezuka, Mighty Atom, Manga/Anime Revolution. Stone Bridge Press. Berkeley.
  • Scolari, C. Bertetti, P. Freeman, M. (2014) Transmedia Archaeology: Storytelling in the Borderlines of Science Fiction, Comics and Pulp Magazines. Palgrave. McMillan.
  • Simon, J. Kirby, J. (1941) Captain America #1. Marvel Comics. New York.
  • Smith, N. (2012) Disney Buys Star Wars maker Lucas film from George Lucas. [Online] BBC News. 31st October. Available from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20146942 [Last Accessed: 23/01/2016]
  • Sobchack V. (1987) Screening Space: The American Science Fiction Film. Rutgers University Press. New Brunswick.
  • Spiegelman, A. (1991) Maus. Pantheon Books. New York.
  • Steinberg, M. (2012) Anime’s Media Mix. Franchising Toys and Characters in Japan. University of Minnesota Press. Minneapolis.
  • Takeda, Y. (2002) The Notenki Memoirs. Studio Gainax and the Men who Created Evangelion. A.D.Vision, Inc. Texas.
  • Taylor, C. (2015) How Star Wars Conquered the Universe. Head of Zeus. London.
  • Thomas, R. et. al. (1977 – 1986) Star Wars. Marvel Comics. New York.
  • Topel, F. (2016) Interview: X-Files Creator Chris Carter on revisiting Mulder & Scully and the Evolution of the Conspiracy Theorist. [Online]. Slash Film. January 22nd. Available from: http://www.slashfilm.com/x-files-chris-carter-interview/ [Last Accessed: 11/02/2016]
  • Vaughn, M. (2014) Kingsman: The Secret Service. [Blu-ray] Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation. Marv Films.
  • Veitch, T. (1991 – 1992) Star Wars: Dark Empire. Dark Horse Comics. Milwaukie.
  • Wachowskis, The. (1999) The Matrix. [Blu-ray] Warner Bros. Village Roadshow Pictures.
  • Wachowskis, The. (2003) The Matrix Reloaded [Blu-ray] Warner Bros. Village Roadshow Pictures. Silver Pictures.
  • Wachowskis, The. (2003) The Matrix Revolution [Blu-ray] Warner Bros. Village Roadshow Pictures. Silver Pictures.
  • Wachowskis, The. Darrow, B. (2003) Bits and Pieces of Information. Burlyman Entertainment. Brooklyn.
  • Watanabe, S. (2003) Kid’s Story. [Blu-ray]. Studio 4C. Warner Home Video.
  • Weaver, T. (2013) Comics. For Film, Games, and Animation. Using Comics to Construct your Transmedia Story World. Focus Press. Burlington.
  • Whitbrock, J. (2015) The long, complicated relationship between Star Wars and Marvel Comics. [Online] iO9. 15th December. Available from: io9.gizmodo.com/the-long-complicated-relationship-between-star-wars-an-1748168985 [Last Accessed: 13/01/2016]
  • Zahn, T. (1991) Star Wars: Heir to the Empire. Bantam Spectra. New York.